Home
Publication Importance
Journals
Overview of a Journal
Structure and Roles of Journal Personnel
Assessing Journals
Journal Impact Factors
Emerging Journal Formats
Journal Papers
The Basics
How to Write a Paper
Reviewing and Publication Process
Ethical Considerations
Getting Involved
Finding, Tracking and Analyzing Citations
How to Review a Paper
Survey of Journal Editors
Publication Timeline
Submission and Reviewing
Acceptance Rates
Publication Advice
Perceived Gender Biases
Related Literature
Full Survey Paper
Videos
How to Use ISI Web of Science
Interviews with Researchers
Examples
Reviews
Page Proofs
Citation Alert Email
References
Index of Terms and Topics
Acknowledgements
Contact Information
Review Examples
First review
Manuscript 1 - Feedback on same manuscript from three reviewers
Four review feedbacks on another manuscript in standard forms
Another example of four first reviews
Responding to a first review
Manuscript 1 - Authors' responses to the 1st reviews on manuscript 1
Another example reply to first reviews
Second review
Manuscript 1 - Second reviews on the same manuscript above
Responding to a second review
Manuscript 1 - Authors' responses to the second reviews on manuscript 1