CD Label
  • Home
  • Publication Importance
  •  
  • Journals
  • Overview of a Journal
  • Structure and Roles of Journal Personnel
  • Assessing Journals
  • Journal Impact Factors
  • Emerging Journal Formats
  •  
  • Journal Papers
  • The Basics
  • How to Write a Paper
  • Reviewing and Publication Process
  • Ethical Considerations
  •  
  • Getting Involved
  • Finding, Tracking and Analyzing Citations
  • How to Review a Paper
  •  
  • Survey of Journal Editors
  • Publication Timeline
  • Submission and Reviewing
  • Acceptance Rates
  • Publication Advice
  • Perceived Gender Biases
  • Related Literature
  • Full Survey Paper
  •  
  • Videos
  • How to Use ISI Web of Science
  • Interviews with Researchers
  •  
  • Examples
  • Reviews
  • Page Proofs
  • Citation Alert Email
  •  
  • References
  •  
  • Index of Terms and Topics
  •  
  • Acknowledgements
  •  
  • Contact Information

Review Examples

First review

  • Manuscript 1 - Feedback on same manuscript from three reviewers
  • Four review feedbacks on another manuscript in standard forms
  • Another example of four first reviews

Responding to a first review

  • Manuscript 1 - Authors' responses to the 1st reviews on manuscript 1
  • Another example reply to first reviews

Second review

  • Manuscript 1 - Second reviews on the same manuscript above

Responding to a second review

  • Manuscript 1 - Authors' responses to the second reviews on manuscript 1

A Guide to Publication Process
by Auburn University Industrial and Systems Engineering